Although the
website was created to make available contemporary photographs,
there are too many interesting churches that have disappeared—except
on old albumen prints or in engravings made for pre-1900 books
and magazines. We solicit such images from our readers and will
reproduce at least one every month, along with such historical
information as we can find about these vanished churches.
If you would like to see an image
in your possession on this site, we are pleased to receive your
own scans, or you may send us the photograph and we will create
a high resolution scan and return the image to you with a copy
of the scan and our thanks!
First
Reformed Church
Pompton Plains, Morris County

This important Dutch Reformed congregation
was formed as a mission of the Ponds church from 1713 to 1736, when it was separately
established. For many years it shared a minister with the Reformed churches in
Fairfield, Montville and Preakness. In 1834 Pompton Plains was described as a “struggling
village with a Dutch Reformed church, a tavern, three stores, an academy, and
about 30 dwellings.”This classic building draws from the Dutch Reformed
architectural tradition established in Bergen country, although its specific
model may have been the Ponds church. It burned in 1938 down to the stone walls,
but was rebuilt authentically. It was erected in 1771 and is the oldest Dutch
Reformed
church
still
standing.